|
Post by SimplyLuscious on Jul 5, 2004 1:31:11 GMT -5
but... (i know, i won't give up on this ) Why, then, didn't Allie say "This is what i've been missing out on all these years?" By her saying just "This is what i've been missing all these years," means that she had it and missed it . Meh, i doesn't really matter but thats just how i saw it... ;D I'm in total agreement with you. I think there was a brief love making between them. But I'm giving up from trying to convince my interpretation on that one scene. Keep up the fight, I think. ;D
|
|
April
Full Member
Posts: 125
|
Post by April on Jul 5, 2004 5:10:18 GMT -5
my interpretation of the scene? hmm..
well for me, it didn't seem as if they had sex the first time since she was nervous and kept talking (which i found hilarious..and so did everyone else in the theater). and then when they meet up 7 years later and she says "this is what i've been missing out blah blah blah", i thought she meant that since it didn't happen before, she finally found out what it..felt like to be with noah in that way? lol i don't know really, but that's how i saw it. =P
|
|
iLuVrYaN
Junior Member
Noah <3s Allie
Posts: 85
|
Post by iLuVrYaN on Jul 5, 2004 11:27:24 GMT -5
Yes exactly! Thats how I veiw it too!!
Btw yeah in the earlier scene I though it was co cute when she was like "Ok nevermind.Mums the word."
|
|
|
Post by lizziebeth on Jul 11, 2004 4:07:20 GMT -5
SORRY! Double Post!
|
|
|
Post by lizziebeth on Jul 11, 2004 4:10:18 GMT -5
The impression I received from the movie was that they did not have sex. I thought that Allie was just kidding around with him when she said "This is what i've been missing all these years " because a second later she was like " let's do it again " or something to that effect. I thought she was trying to pull his chain by being sassy. That's JMHO though.
|
|
chxo
New Member
Posts: 35
|
Post by chxo on Jul 11, 2004 17:47:44 GMT -5
In the book they do actually have sex the night in the broken down house, but in the movie I don't think they do...I got the impression that they almost did, and if they did, only for a second.
-ch
|
|
AznIntegra521
Full Member
Why didnt u write me? I've waited for you for seven years.
Posts: 150
|
Post by AznIntegra521 on Jul 11, 2004 17:55:09 GMT -5
in the book they had sex alot.
|
|
shellyboo1217
Junior Member
Maybe I was a bird in another life.
Posts: 77
|
Post by shellyboo1217 on Jul 11, 2004 21:37:55 GMT -5
hahaha i guess...
|
|
|
Post by SimplyLuscious on Jul 11, 2004 21:42:08 GMT -5
Not really was it? If I'm not wrong, wasn't it like three or four times. One was in the beginning, second was when they reunited, and last was the ending when they were really old and she remembered him briefly (but I just think they were dying. Two old folks doing it is hard for me to picture).
|
|
|
Post by katryna on Jul 11, 2004 22:11:11 GMT -5
Ewww.....no . I don't believe they had sex at the end of the book...as much as i love allie and noah, thats just gross. and besides, i don't think noah was exactly pysically capable...lol. from the very first time i read the book, i thought they died together at the very end and they were making love in heaven, where they finally could be "young again," in love and remembering each other fully. yeah, they have sex a lot in the book...haha. when they're teenagers, then when they're reunited, they do it looottttsss of times.
|
|
|
Post by SimplyLuscious on Jul 11, 2004 22:26:30 GMT -5
I know... Eww!!! Lol...
|
|
shellyboo1217
Junior Member
Maybe I was a bird in another life.
Posts: 77
|
Post by shellyboo1217 on Jul 11, 2004 22:43:56 GMT -5
Ewww.....no . I don't believe they had sex at the end of the book...as much as i love allie and noah, thats just gross. and besides, i don't think noah was exactly pysically capable...lol. from the very first time i read the book, i thought they died together at the very end and they were making love in heaven, where they finally could be "young again," in love and remembering each other fully. yeah, they have sex a lot in the book...haha. when they're teenagers, then when they're reunited, they do it looottttsss of times. haha after finishing the book i thought they were having sex too.. and i was like.. eww! but i never thought about them being young again and making love in heaven.. thats a really good insight! thanks for sharing
|
|
|
Post by lindseyloo72001 on Jul 14, 2004 0:19:28 GMT -5
"in the first scene, in the broken down house...they did have sex...but just for a second
remember noah says "am i hurting you?"
err...i dont think he would have said that if they were just kissing "
Noah does, indeed, say "Are you alright?" and "Did I hurt you?" But I don't think they really had sex. When he asks "Did I hurt you?", it could be because he thought he was crushing her. Someone on another board, however, pointed out that maybe he said this because he was *trying* to make love to her, but she was nervous, and maybe he just simply couldn't, anatomically, if you know what I mean. Maybe he had been trying, unsuccessfully, when she stopped him. Anyway, that's my take on this...
|
|
grkANGEL85
Full Member
Summer Romances are shooting stars. A specacular moment of light from the Heavens.
Posts: 204
|
Post by grkANGEL85 on Jul 14, 2004 0:38:27 GMT -5
Interesting topic. It makes me think, which I like.
My take on the subject. I do think they came very close to having sex in the old house. I don't want to say anything that would offend anyone or whatever, but maybe he pulled out before anything happened when she started to freak out on him? That's what I think.
Then when she says, "this is what I've been missing out on..." I think she means with Noah specifically.
|
|
iLuVrYaN
Junior Member
Noah <3s Allie
Posts: 85
|
Post by iLuVrYaN on Jul 14, 2004 16:44:40 GMT -5
I don't think they did. I mean we see the whole scene-
They lay down kiss she gets nervous they sit up talk Fin walks in and they're in the same position as they sat up
Trust me Guys if they had sex in that scene-We'd know it. Especially if she was a virgin.
Guys u can miss out on something u;ve never done before! I mean I missed out on going parasailing with my friends when I could've but I never did and still haven't
|
|