Ending - Happy or Sad?

[grkANGEL85]

The ending can be determined as happy or sad, in my opinion. What did you all think, happy or sad ending and why?

I'm going to go with happy. Because they died together. It's like Allie said, "do you think our love can take us away?" I'm going to get a little religous here, but I believe that when you die, you are reunited with loved ones and are living in happiness. This is why I think that the ending was happy, because neither one was feeling pain anymore.

[LadyKatie]

I didn't cry sad tears... I cried "moving" tears if that makes sence. I was moved by the ending. I can't say I was happy or sad... just moved.

[ALLIEnNOAH4ever]

I think it's happy cuz their were together for all those years and that they had shared such a beautiful love that your sad to see it end, you want more..I'm happy that she knew who Noah was and how much he and she meant to the both of them and when they were seprated from each other during the war they were both misriable (sp?), not so much for Allie as it is for Noah, but if one of them had died before the other it would have been unbearable for either one not to have each other...

[SimplyLuscious]

Happy because they were able to die together and will live happily in heaven together.

I hate endings with one living and one is dead. Both gone is good.

[katryna]

happy...they were both finally together up in heaven with all the memories they wanted of each other

but that still doesn't mean i didn't bawl my bloody eyes out...haha.

[grkANGEL85]

ALLIEnNOAH4ever said:

I think it's happy cuz their were together for all those years and that they had shared such a beautiful love that your sad to see it end, you want more..I'm happy that she knew who Noah was and how much he and she meant to the both of them and when they were seprated from each other during the war they were both misriable (sp?), not so much for Allie as it is for Noah, but if one of them had died before the other it would have been unbearable for either one not to have each other...

I agree with you 100%! I basically said the same thing in the review section about not wanting to see their love story end. Even though they spent their lives together, it doesn't seem like it was enough...they deserved more. And I guess you can say they have eternity to be together.

I also agree with what you said about one of them dying. That's what I told my friend when she said it was so unrealistic that they just died right there together. I told her that it was better that way. They both just let go, you know? I think Noah was ready to go for a while, he was just waiting for Allie. I believe that if Allie died first, he would just find a way to die himself.

[AznIntegra521]

definitly happy becoz they were together finally after all they went through when they were litto and being together and rising such a great family. Now they get to b together for all entinity.

[April]

happy. and everyone else pretty much stated my reasons

[shellyboo1217]

LadyKatie said:

I didn't cry sad tears... I cried "moving" tears if that makes sence. I was moved by the ending. I can't say I was happy or sad... just moved.

yeah same here..

[chxo]

LadyKatie said:

I didn't cry sad tears... I cried "moving" tears if that makes sence. I was moved by the ending. I can't say I was happy or sad... just moved.

ditto! Thats exactly how i felt

-ch

[yukon1492]

this is an appropriate ending for couple with life-long
devotion and affection for each other.

[ThoseSummerNights]

It's a bittersweet ending, in that even though Allie has alzheimer's, she is still able to remember Noah at times, and even though they die, they die together.

[Kwin]

i think it's a happy ending. they both died together in each other's arms. their love did take them away together and that is beautful it's better than noah dying first and leaving allie with her alzheimer's all alone or allie dying first and noah moving on as a sad, lonely man...