|
Martha
Aug 5, 2004 20:36:51 GMT -5
Post by ILoveNoah on Aug 5, 2004 20:36:51 GMT -5
Okay guys. I have a question. You know how Martha just shows up at Noah's house. Well, when Allie comes out, she says that she's heard a lot about Martha. Do you think this is a lie? Do you think she was just standing by the door and wanted to be nice and pretend like Noah was talking about her like he was about Allie? Obviously Martha knew who Allie was, so do you think Allie knew who Martha was?
|
|
|
Martha
Aug 5, 2004 23:06:40 GMT -5
Post by katryna on Aug 5, 2004 23:06:40 GMT -5
I believe that Martha knew of Allie, more so as an ideal, not a real person- ya know? Its kinda hard to explain, but i don't believe Noah ever told Martha about Allie...Martha just knew that there was always "someone else" who she'd never compare to- and that someone was Allie.
I can't really see Noah saying anything to Allie about Martha...i think she might've been saying it just to be nice. But hey, there might've been a deleted scene where he told her, haha.
|
|
|
Martha
Aug 6, 2004 0:06:30 GMT -5
Post by memorylane on Aug 6, 2004 0:06:30 GMT -5
I can't really see Noah saying anything to Allie about Martha...i think she might've been saying it just to be nice. But hey, there might've been a deleted scene where he told her, haha. I agree. Really, who wants to hear about the woman your guy was with before you? What guy wants to tell? Besides, Noah had more important things to say to Allie.
|
|
Mary-Lynn
Full Member
It wasn't over, It still isn't over
Posts: 204
|
Martha
Aug 6, 2004 0:10:39 GMT -5
Post by Mary-Lynn on Aug 6, 2004 0:10:39 GMT -5
I believe that Martha knew of Allie, more so as an ideal, not a real person- ya know? Its kinda hard to explain, but i don't believe Noah ever told Martha about Allie...Martha just knew that there was always "someone else" who she'd never compare to- and that someone was Allie. I can't really see Noah saying anything to Allie about Martha...i think she might've been saying it just to be nice. But hey, there might've been a deleted scene where he told her, haha. yes I agree with that, I think Allie was being polite.And I think Allie and Noah had more inportant things to talk about other then the Girl he was sleeping with
|
|
|
Martha
Aug 6, 2004 13:03:58 GMT -5
Post by Kwin on Aug 6, 2004 13:03:58 GMT -5
even if noah told allie about martha, he probably wouldn't have told her that she was someone he was sleeping with. he probably mentioned her as a friend or something.
however, if noah never told allie about martha, how did she know her name when martha showed up at the door?
|
|
iLuVrYaN
Junior Member
Noah <3s Allie
Posts: 85
|
Martha
Aug 7, 2004 10:13:27 GMT -5
Post by iLuVrYaN on Aug 7, 2004 10:13:27 GMT -5
I think Noah did mention Martha to Allie. They started off their renewal as just friends, and as we know that didn't work out to well I'm thinking, you know that since they started out to be friends that first day,It would have been fine for Noah to tell her he was seeing someone.
|
|
|
Martha
Aug 7, 2004 22:52:33 GMT -5
Post by trueloverawks on Aug 7, 2004 22:52:33 GMT -5
Martha always knew that Noah had someone else before her... she was just a substitute until she came back... i hate to say that but i think thats true at least to me... I dont think Allie knew about Martha... maybe she did.... i dunno... But thats the thing about Allie she was really polite no matter what.. she knew that noah had his own affairs to deal with... and dont you remember that martha told noah that allie was just extradorinary... proven fact i think...
|
|
|
Martha
Aug 11, 2004 15:10:56 GMT -5
Post by ThoseSummerNights on Aug 11, 2004 15:10:56 GMT -5
Allie was told all about Martha by Noah in the book. So I'm assuming the same goes for the movie, even though we don't have a scene that shows him talking about her. I think Martha was also told about Allie, but in a non- specific way. Like she said, a woman just knows.
|
|
|
Martha
Aug 15, 2004 19:51:56 GMT -5
Post by dearcass on Aug 15, 2004 19:51:56 GMT -5
I just assumed Allie was listening to the conversation and overheard Noah say "Martha." Allie came out right after Martha asked to meet her (to me, that's why Allie came out) and Noah said "I don't think that's a good idea, Martha."
|
|