Which do u prefer?

[LadyKatie]

I think the book is just as good as the movie..
well the move is probably a little better because of the beautiful people.
but they each bring excellent qualities to the table.

[katryna]

LadyKatie said:

but they each bring excellent qualities to the table.

yes, especially to the table scene...oh, but wait...we didn't get to see that because of the freakin pg-13 ratings sorry, had to add that ;-)

i think they both have their strong points...but i like the movie because they had more of the teenage years, and because noah and allie's chemistry comes alive in the movie. the book can't describe the way rachel and ryan look at each other onscreen...*sigh* its just so beautiful and passionate